Gratitude and Grief: The History Behind the Thanksgiving Divide

As families prepare to give thanks Thursday, Native people will gather in Plymouth for the 57th National Day of Mourning, steps from where the holiday's origin story began.

By EEW Magazine Online Editors

The statue of the Wampanoag leader Ousamequin, known by his title Massasoit, on Cole's Hill in Plymouth, Massachusetts, during the town's 1921 tercentenary celebration. The National Day of Mourning gathers beside it each Thanksgiving. (Edward P. McLaughlin/Plymouth Public Library)

On Thursday, as families across the country gather around turkey and dressing and bow their heads to give thanks, another gathering will take place on Cole's Hill in Plymouth, Massachusetts. At noon, Native people and their supporters will meet beside a statue of the Wampanoag leader Ousamequin, overlooking Plymouth Rock, for the 57th National Day of Mourning.

The town says the event will proceed as scheduled, even as it and the organizers argue in court over its stage. A plaque on the hill explains why they come: many Native Americans do not celebrate the arrival of the Pilgrims and other European settlers.

The holiday means very different things to different Americans. About nine in 10 celebrate Thanksgiving, according to a 2024 Pew Research Center survey, and in many Christian homes the meal starts with prayer. The story behind the holiday draws far less agreement. In a 2021 Economist/YouGov poll, 49% of Americans said the Pilgrims stole Native land, and 23% said they settled in abandoned areas.

The title page of Mourt's Relation, printed in London in 1622, which contains Edward Winslow's account of the 1621 harvest gathering. (Public domain)

The familiar story of the first Thanksgiving rests on a brief record. In the autumn of 1621, after the English colonists at Plymouth brought in their first harvest, colonist Edward Winslow wrote to a friend in England, "God be praised, we had a good increase of Indian corn." Ousamequin, known to the colonists by his title, Massasoit, came to the settlement with about 90 men, and the English entertained and feasted them for three days. The Wampanoag went out and killed five deer, which they gave to the governor and others.

Winslow's letter, printed in London in 1622, is the only surviving eyewitness account of the gathering Americans now call the first Thanksgiving.

Winslow does not say why the Wampanoag came. He does note that the colonists "exercised our arms" during the celebration, firing their guns. Wampanoag accounts say the men arrived after hearing that gunfire.

Anita "Mother Bear" Peters, a Mashpee Wampanoag clan mother, told NPR in 2021 that her ancestors were not invited and heard the shots in the distance. Her cousin, Mashpee Wampanoag historian Paula Peters, told the network that her ancestors suffered great injustice after that harvest meal.

The Wampanoag had kept harvest ceremonies and seasonal thanksgiving for thousands of years before the Mayflower arrived, according to the Smithsonian's National Museum of the American Indian. By then, their communities had suffered a catastrophe. An epidemic that swept the New England coast from 1616 to 1619 killed 75% to 90% of the Wampanoag people, according to Pilgrim Hall Museum, and the colonists built Plymouth on the site of Patuxet, a village the disease had emptied.

In March 1621, Ousamequin entered into a mutual protection agreement with the colonists. The alliance endured for decades, though tensions grew as English settlements spread onto Native land. In 1675, his son Metacom, whom the English called King Philip, led a war against the colonists that Britannica ranks among the bloodiest per capita in American history. Metacom was killed in 1676, and hundreds of Native captives were sold into slavery.

The national holiday came more than two centuries later, nine months after the Emancipation Proclamation took effect and with the Civil War raging. After decades of campaigning by Sarah Josepha Hale, editor of Godey's Lady's Book, President Abraham Lincoln issued a proclamation on Oct. 3, 1863, setting apart the last Thursday of November as a day of thanksgiving and praise to God.

Sarah Josepha Hale, editor of Godey's Lady's Book, in a portrait by James Reid Lambdin, around 1831. She campaigned for decades for a national day of thanksgiving. (Richards Free Library/Wikimedia Commons)

Lincoln's proclamation asked Americans to offer their thanks with "humble penitence for our national perverseness and disobedience" and to commend to God's care "all those who have become widows, orphans, mourners, or sufferers" of the war. Congress fixed the holiday on the fourth Thursday of November in 1941, by which time the Plymouth harvest had become its best-known origin story.

Lincoln's 1863 Thanksgiving proclamation asked Americans to pair their thanks with "humble penitence" and to commend to God's care "widows, orphans, mourners, or sufferers" of the Civil War. (National Archives)

In 1970, that story met public resistance. Massachusetts marked the 350th anniversary of the Pilgrims' landing and invited Wamsutta Frank James, an Aquinnah Wampanoag leader, to speak at the commemoration. Organizers reviewed his remarks in advance and would not let him deliver them. That Thanksgiving, James and his supporters went to Cole's Hill and held the first National Day of Mourning beside the statue of Ousamequin. The group he founded, the United American Indians of New England, has led the gathering there every year since.

Native views of the holiday differ. Dennis Zotigh, a writer and cultural specialist at the National Museum of the American Indian, has collected responses from Native readers for a recurring Smithsonian essay. Some gather with relatives for a meal with little thought of 1621. Some point to older harvest ceremonies, such as the Green Corn ceremony, as the roots of giving thanks, and some attend powwows or mark a Day of Mourning. Others do not observe the holiday at all.

Paula Peters has expressed both views herself. "We don't acknowledge the American holiday of Thanksgiving," she told The Washington Post in 2021. In her NPR interview that year, she said she foresees a time when people "can celebrate Thanksgiving and still acknowledge the real truth of the story."

Gratitude appears throughout this history, in Wampanoag harvest ceremonies, in Winslow's praise for the corn and in Lincoln's call to worship. The disagreement over Thanksgiving centers on what followed that first harvest and how the nation remembers it. For the organizers on Cole's Hill, the conversation also extends to the Native communities of today.

The Wampanoag remain on their homelands in southeastern Massachusetts. The Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe and the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah) are federally recognized nations. Each October, members of the Aquinnah tribe go to the cranberry bogs on Martha's Vineyard to gather berries and give thanks for the harvest, a tradition known as Cranberry Day.

On Thursday, prayers of thanks will be offered at family tables across the country. Prayers will also be offered on Cole's Hill, as they have been every Thanksgiving for more than half a century.

Watch the Report
Native American group sues Plymouth over National Day of Mourning dispute
Video: CBS Boston
Next
Next

After a $62.2 Million Verdict, Word Network Founder Kevin Adell Lays Out His Debts in Bankruptcy Court