The Superwoman Schema: Strong for Everyone, Even When the Holidays Wear Her Down

She plans the meal, remembers every need and rarely admits she is tired. New research shows the toll on Black women, and how families can share the load.

By EEW Magazine Online Editors

For many Black women, the expectation to be the strong one grows heavier at the holidays.

Weeks before the turkey goes into the oven, she has already been at work. She has worked out the guest list, the menu, the grocery budget and the seating. She remembers that one relative doesn't eat pork, another needs a ride and a third will be hurt without an invitation. Then Thanksgiving arrives. Somebody tells her what a wonderful job she has done, and she smiles and says thank you.

Few at the table realize that most of the work happened inside her head, well before anyone walked through the door.

Researchers call it the mental load, and women shoulder far more of it during the holidays. A LifeStance Health survey of 1,000 U.S. adults, released Nov. 13, found that 55% of women strongly agree they carry the holiday mental load in their household, compared with 37% of men. Nearly half of women, 46%, said they put their physical and mental health on hold during busy seasons like this one.

The cooking is only the visible part of the work behind a holiday meal. (Dimensions/Getty Images)

For many Black women, the load comes with another expectation: the belief that she must always be strong, dependable and available to anyone who needs her. Psychologists study this pattern as the Superwoman Schema, which includes pressure to project strength, hold back emotion, resist vulnerability and help others at her own expense.

A 2025 study in Ethnicity & Health grouped 167 young Black women, with an average age of 22, by how strongly they held to those pressures. The group researchers called Guarded Caregivers, marked by high emotional suppression, reluctance to show vulnerability and a strong sense of obligation to help others, reported the highest stress of any group. The study did not examine the holidays, and its participants were younger than many women hosting Thanksgiving. Still, it offers a window into why some women find it hard to admit when the load has grown too heavy.

Taisha Caldwell-Harvey, a licensed psychologist and founder of The Black Girl Doctor, has written about the same pressures at holiday time. In a holiday post on her site, she points to the family obligation to host because "you've always done it," the unspoken expectation that Black women will hold everything together, workplace demands and self-imposed perfectionism.

Taisha Caldwell-Harvey, a licensed psychologist and founder of The Black Girl Doctor, says many Black women feel unspoken pressure to hold everything together during the holidays.

Sometimes the pressure comes out loud. A relative expects her to host because she always has. A church committee assumes she will coordinate one more event. Other times nobody has to ask. She simply assumes everything is hers to manage, and because she handles it so well, the people around her may never see what that competence costs.

The mental load is the planning behind the chores: anticipating needs, tracking details and writing the list someone else takes to the store. That helps explain why a woman can feel overwhelmed even when her family pitches in. In a 2024 study of 322 mothers of young children, published in Archives of Women's Mental Health, mothers reported doing about 73% of the planning and 64% of the hands-on work. Those who held more of the planning reported more depression, stress and burnout.

The holidays add to the pile. Sociologists have for decades used the term "second shift" for the housework and child care women take on after a day of paid work. Writing for Contexts in 2025, Kate Prickett and Jennifer Augustine describe the holiday season as a third shift for mothers, who take on considerably more holiday housework and shopping than fathers.

Many women love this work, from their grandmother's recipes to the full table. The strain comes from the expectation that one person will keep doing all of it, year after year, whatever her health or capacity. A woman can love her family deeply and still be exhausted by the responsibility of making every celebration happen.

For many women, passing down family recipes is part of the joy of the season.

Part of the reason the load persists is that helping with a task and owning it are two separate things. Picture her on Thanksgiving morning. Her husband asks what he can do, and she tells him to peel the potatoes. Her adult daughter offers to set the table. A nephew volunteers for the dishes. She appreciates every one of them, and she is still the one deciding what needs doing, handing out assignments, explaining how she wants it done and checking the results. She remains the manager of the whole celebration.

Sharing the mental load means someone takes responsibility for a complete task, including the thinking that comes before it. A family member might take charge of two dishes, from choosing the recipes to checking the pantry, buying the ingredients and cooking. Another might handle the guest list, confirm who is coming and arrange the seating without waiting for instructions. An exhausted woman has little use for one more person asking her to write a list. She needs someone willing to take part of the work off her mind.

Changing old patterns can feel uncomfortable, especially when traditions run deep. Maybe a mother has cooked the same elaborate dinner for 30 years, and the family talks about it for months. Now she is older, managing a chronic illness or working longer hours. Perhaps money is tighter, or she is grieving someone who used to sit at that table. The tradition may still mean the world to her. What has to change is the assumption that she will keep it alive by herself.

Families can keep what they love and change how it gets done. That might mean fewer dishes, every household bringing part of the meal, a store-bought dessert in place of one made from scratch, or grown children taking over arrangements they once left to their mother. It may also mean asking one honest question before the holiday arrives: What would make this celebration enjoyable for the person who usually organizes it?

Research links the pressure to be strong for everyone to higher stress among Black women, a weight the holidays can make heavier. (Fotostorm/Getty Images)

The American Psychological Association encourages parents to set realistic expectations for the holidays and to accept help from the people who care about them. A practical first step is to lay out the full workload before preparations begin, from cooking and cleaning to budgeting, transportation, invitations and coordinating relatives. Then the family can decide together what to share, simplify or drop.

Women accustomed to managing everything may also need to resist supervising every detail once the work is handed off. Someone else's macaroni and cheese may not taste like hers, and the table will still be full.

Not every woman has relatives willing or able to step in. Single mothers, caregivers and women living alone may have fewer people to lean on. For them, a simpler celebration, help from church or community, and the freedom to leave some things undone can make the season lighter.

There is an irony in a season devoted to gratitude and togetherness wearing down the very women who make it possible. The woman who cooked the meal should get to sit down and savor it with everyone else.

This Thanksgiving, look past the beautiful table and the cherished traditions to the person who has been holding everything together. Then do more than thank her.

Take some of the responsibility off her shoulders, so she can enjoy the holiday, too.

Previous
Previous

1,600 Black Mothers Speak Out About Childbirth. Nearly Half Say They Felt Judged by Their Care Teams.

Next
Next

Measles During Pregnancy: New CDC Findings Reveal Serious Risks for Mothers and Babies